Hi everyone
I finished my fourth novel by Emma Donoghue; Akin. I read this on my e-reader.
"Noah is only days away from his first trip back to Nice since he was a child when a social worker calls looking for a temporary home for Michael, his eleven-year-old great-nephew. Though he has never met the boy, he gets talked into taking him along to France.
This odd couple, suffering from jet lag and culture shock, argue about everything from steak haché to screen time, and the trip is looking like a disaster. But as Michael's sharp eye and ease with tech help Noah unearth troubling details about their family’s past, both come to grasp the risks that loved ones take for one another, and find they are more akin than they knew.
Written with all the tenderness and psychological intensity that made Room a huge bestseller, Akin is a funny, heart-wrenching tale of an old man and a young boy who unpick their painful stories and embark on writing a new one together."
This was also a mixed reading experience for me.
The setup of Noah fostering Michael is really ridiculous. Things might be different in America, but here in Belgium? I really can’t see this happening the way it did in the novel. In just a couple of days, 80-year-old Noah meets Michael, is approved to foster him, meets the mother in prison, and is allowed to travel to another continent with him; AND all tickets and reservations just work out. Absurd.
The way Noah talks is so cringe. He’s like a walking tourist guide in a country he realistically shouldn’t remember a thing about because he left when he was four. Who has so many detailed memories from their toddler years? No one. And then, for someone who’s so clever and knows so many utterly boring things, he’s not very smart when it comes to solving the mystery. Instead, it’s eleven-year-old Michael who doesn’t read like an eleven-year-old. I can’t imagine an American boy of that age not knowing you shouldn’t joke about gun violence in public. Both characters felt very unrealistic.
And the constant "teaching" was so boring to read! It felt like I was reading a textbook.
I enjoyed the mystery in this novel. It was too easily solved, and I guessed long before the end, but it was a good way of opening up a conversation about the Second World War. I very much liked the discussion about collaborators and the resistance, and Le Réseau Marcel; something we actually learned about in school.
Akin had some interesting moments, but the unrealistic setup and flat characters made it hard to fully enjoy. Still, the historical mystery was a highlight for me.
Have you read Akin? Did you enjoy it more than I did, or did you feel the same way? I’d love to hear your thoughts!
Happy reading!
Helena









